Rower vs. Treadmill: Which is right for you?
June 23, 2024

Hey fitness friends! Let’s talk about two popular pieces of cardio equipment: rowing machines and treadmills. Both offer incredible benefits, but depending on your fitness goals and preferences, you might find one suits you better than the other. Let’s dive into the pros and cons of each, and some optional workouts to spice things up!

Rowing Machines: Total Body Burn

Benefits:

  • Full-Body Workout: Rowing machines engage nearly every muscle group, from your legs to your core to your upper body. It's a fantastic way to get a full-body workout in one go.
  • Low Impact: If you’re concerned about joint health, rowing is a great option. The smooth, gliding motion minimizes stress on your knees and hips.
  • Cardio and Strength Combo: Rowing isn’t just about cardio; it also builds strength, particularly in your back, shoulders, and arms.

Drawbacks:

  • Learning Curve: Proper form is crucial to avoid injury and get the most out of your workout. It can take some time to master the rowing technique.
  • Monotony: Some people might find the repetitive motion of rowing less engaging compared to the varied paces and inclines of a treadmill.

Workouts:

  • Interval Training: Alternate between 1 minute of intense rowing and 2 minutes of steady-state rowing for 20-30 minutes.
  • Endurance Row: Aim for a steady, moderate pace for 30-45 minutes to build cardiovascular endurance and stamina.
  • Pyramid Workout: Increase your rowing time incrementally (1 minute, 2 minutes, 3 minutes) and then decrease it, with rest intervals in between.

Treadmills: Run, Walk, Repeat

Benefits:

  • Variety of Workouts: Treadmills offer a range of options, from walking to sprinting, and you can adjust the incline for added intensity.
  • Accessible for All Fitness Levels: Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned runner, treadmills can be customized to your fitness level.
  • Convenient and Controlled Environment: You can walk, jog, or run regardless of weather conditions, making it a reliable option year-round.

Drawbacks:

  • High Impact: Running on a treadmill can be hard on your joints, especially if you're not using proper footwear or if you have preexisting joint issues.
  • Limited Upper Body Engagement: Treadmills primarily work your lower body, so you might need to incorporate other exercises to balance your workout routine.

Workouts:

  • Hill Intervals: Increase the incline for 1-2 minutes, then return to a flat surface for 1 minute. Repeat for 20-30 minutes.
  • Sprint Intervals: Alternate between 30 seconds of sprinting and 1 minute of walking or jogging for a high-intensity workout.
  • Steady-State Run: Maintain a comfortable, consistent pace for 30-60 minutes to build endurance and cardiovascular health.

My Take

Personally, I love the full-body workout and low-impact nature of rowing machines. They’re fantastic for days when I want to engage my entire body without putting too much strain on my joints. Plus, the combination of cardio and strength training is a big win in my book.

On the other hand, treadmills are unbeatable for their versatility and accessibility. They’re perfect for a quick cardio session, and the ability to adjust speed and incline keeps things interesting. However, I do find that running on a treadmill can be a bit repetitive and tough on the knees over time.

Final Thoughts

Both rowing machines and treadmills have their unique advantages. If you’re looking for a comprehensive workout that engages multiple muscle groups and is easy on the joints, rowing might be your best bet. If you prefer variety, the ability to adjust intensity easily, and enjoy the simplicity of walking or running, treadmills are a fantastic choice.

Ultimately, the best piece of equipment is the one that you’ll use consistently and enjoy. Mix it up, try both, and see which one fits your fitness journey best!

Yes You Can!

Morgan